A Consented Site Isn't Always a Clear Site: What the Title Showed on a Central Auckland Mortgagee Sale

Resource consent, building consent and engineering plan approval, and still no right to run a wastewater pipe to the street. What a title review found on a consented central Auckland site.

IlyaDirector and Development Manager
15 November 20264 min read
A grassy rear section behind neighbouring houses in Auckland (not the site in this article)

The site

The site was a rear section in central Auckland with resource consent, building consent and engineering plan approval for three townhouses. It was being sold by the mortgagee, and some earthworks had been started and stopped. Nobody could tell us much about them.

On paper it looked like most of the hard work was done. Consenting is slow and expensive, and a site that already has all three approvals can save a buyer a year or more. We had the title reviewed before going any further, and that's where the questions started.

What the title showed

The right of way covered access only. The driveway ran over a right of way created in 1989, in perpetuity. It gave vehicle and pedestrian access to the site, but it didn't allow services to be installed under it. Running stormwater and wastewater pipes down that driveway needed a new easement over the neighbouring land. That land is an apartment complex, so the apartment owners, through their body corporate, would have to agree.

A services easement covered some things but not all. A separate easement, required by the council when the land was first subdivided, allowed private electricity, water, gas and telecommunications lines to be installed without the neighbour's consent. If Vector or Chorus wanted easements in their own name, though, the apartment owners would have to agree to those too.

There was no right to drain wastewater. Nothing on the title gave the site a right to drain wastewater over the neighbouring land. Whatever the engineering plans showed, the connection couldn't be built without the apartment owners agreeing to a new easement.

There was a charge for unpaid development contributions. Auckland Council had registered a statutory land charge of about $14,500 + GST under section 208 of the Local Government Act 2002, for development contributions that hadn't been paid. There was also a second charge registered on the title, which has to be dealt with at settlement.

Why the consents didn't catch it

A consent assesses whether the development meets the rules. It doesn't check that the owner has the private legal rights to put pipes through someone else's land. The engineering plans can show a perfectly good connection that the title doesn't allow, and that isn't part of what the council is assessing.

In our experience it's worth extra care on rear sites, on sites with older rights of way, and on mortgagee sales, where the history is layered and the seller can't answer questions.

What it means for a buyer

Some of these issues can be solved with time and money. Needing the owners of a whole apartment complex to agree is the one that could stop the project altogether. Even with a single neighbour it isn't simple. On one of our projects in Henderson, the neighbour opened at $100,000 for access to a manhole (we wrote about that in our wastewater connection article). With many owners involved, getting agreement can take a long time, or not happen at all. Vector or Chorus easements add another set of paperwork and another sign-off from the neighbours. The development contribution charge has to be paid or allowed for. All of that belongs in the feasibility before you bid.

What we check on a consented site

  1. The title and every instrument on it, read against the engineering plans, not just listed. That includes checking the driveway on the ground sits where the easement is on the title plan, because land is often subdivided again after an easement is created.
  2. A map of where each service needs to run, what right exists for each one, and who owns the land it crosses.
  3. Whether Vector and Chorus will want their own easements.
  4. Charges registered on the title, including development contributions.
  5. What's physically happened on site since the consent, including any earthworks.

Words explained

Right of way: an easement giving the right to pass over someone else's land, usually by vehicle and on foot.

Services easement: an easement giving the right to install and keep pipes or cables in someone else's land.

Statutory land charge: a charge registered on the title by a council for money owed, which a buyer needs to deal with.

Engineering plan approval: the council's approval of the civil design, such as drainage and services.

Share this article

FAQ

Frequently asked questions

Not the private rights you need to cross a neighbour's land. That's a legal question for the owner.

Sources & context